Request demo
fr nl
Back to the blog Customer Experience

Customer experience in insurance: the claim is the experience

Bram De VosBram De Vos 18 min read

Customer experience in insurance is everything a customer goes through with an insurer, from the quote to the renewal. For most customers it is decided in one place: the claim. Years of premiums buy a promise, and the claim is the only moment it is tested. Across the EU, 17% of consumers who made a claim in the past two years were dissatisfied, and 16% believe their claim was wrongly denied. Claims handling made up 52% of all non-life complaints that insurers themselves handled in 2024. This article maps where insurance CX breaks, using ombudsman and regulator data from four countries, and names the five moments inside a claim that decide the renewal.

Key takeaways:

  • The claim is the relationship. Refused payouts, slow settlement and unresponsive handling are the top three reasons claimants are dissatisfied in the EU, and the Belgian, Dutch, French and UK complaint maps say the same thing in their own numbers.
  • Referrals to the French insurance mediator rose 28% in 2025 to 46,830, three times the 2020 level. Requests to the Belgian ombudsman rose 13% to 9,429. The volume is growing faster than the market.
  • Satisfaction drops after the payout, not during reporting. US auto claimants rate a repairable claim higher every year; a total loss scored 46 points lower than in 2023, and 490 out of 1,000 when the cheque did not cover the loan.
  • Five moments inside one claim deserve their own measurement: first notice, the document request, the silence, the decision, and the payout and after. An annual relationship score averages them away.
  • Brokers hold 61% of Belgian non-life premiums, so a large share of the feedback never reaches the insurer unless the broker channel is measured on its own.

What customer experience in insurance means

Customer experience in insurance is the impression a customer forms of an insurer across every contact, and those contacts are rare. A policy is bought once, renewed by silence and tested only when something goes wrong. Horst Remes put it plainly on our CX Matters podcast: "Why do we have insurance? We are buying peace of mind." He called the monetary value of peace of mind one of the most underestimated things in business.

That makes insurance different from telecom or banking, where the app is used daily. Here the premium notice, the renewal letter and the claim are the relationship, and the claim carries almost all the weight. The American Customer Satisfaction Index puts the US property and casualty industry at 76 out of 100 this year, with a 16-point spread between the best and the worst insurer. Agent courtesy, call centre satisfaction and claims processing speed all improved, and all three are human or claim-related. Forrest Morgeson, the index's director of research emeritus, said that until AI shows up in those moments, "the human side of insurance will carry most of the weight".

Why insurance satisfaction numbers hide the risk

Most of an insurer's customers have never claimed. They are satisfied the way a person is satisfied with a smoke alarm that has never gone off. EIOPA's 2025 Eurobarometer found 62% of EU claimants satisfied with how their claim was handled and 17% not. The reasons for the 17% are precise: a payout lower than expected (23%), a process that took too long (22%), an unhelpful or unresponsive claims service (21%), unclear policy terms that led to an unexpected denial (20%) and excessive or repeated documentation (19%). Each one is an experience problem before it is a legal one.

The second reason the numbers mislead is that a claim has two halves. In J.D. Power's 2026 US auto claims study, overall satisfaction held at 700 out of 1,000, but it rose 4 points when the car could be repaired and fell 12 points when it was a total loss. Total loss satisfaction has fallen for three years running, 46 points since 2023, and total losses are now 26% of claims, up from 16% four years ago. When the payout did not cover the loan, satisfaction was 490. A quarter of total loss customers with a loan were paid less than they owed. The report of the claim went fine. The memory is made at the money.

The third reason is that the unhappy do not stay silent for long. France's insurance mediator received 46,830 referrals in 2025, 28% more than in 2024 and three times the 15,000 of 2020. Three quarters arrive online, and the mediator notes that claimants increasingly use AI tools to write them. The mediator's own verdict on the cause: "les services réclamation sont parfois insuffisants". Our guide to customer churn covers how to measure the leak; in insurance it shows up at renewal, a year after the claim that caused it.

Where insurance CX breaks: a complaint map from four countries

Ombudsmen and regulators publish what customers escalate. In insurance, one theme sits at the top of every list: the claim that was refused, delayed or never explained.

Country, source, yearWhat customers escalate
Belgium, Ombudsman van de Verzekeringen, 20259,429 requests, up 13%. Motor 1,697 (+15%), fire 1,386, health 1,205 (+18%), life 1,053, legal expenses 1,047 (+36%). Requests about car theft more than doubled, mostly refusals of cover. Two findings: chatbots and automated platforms give standardised answers that do not fit individual cases, with no human reachable by phone, and long claim settlement times caused by competing expert assessments
Netherlands, AFM, 2025170 insurers reported about 121,000 complaints, down 3.2% overall. Non-life was the only segment to rise, up 5.1% to 53,700, with legal expenses insurance up 24.8%
France, Médiation de l'Assurance, 202546,830 referrals, up 28%. Refusal of cover is 55% of admissible files, and the mediator notes the reasons for refusal are still very often not understood by the insured. Motor referrals up 81%, home up 48%, loan insurance up 77%, complementary health up 97%
UK, FCA, first half of 2026722,974 complaints about insurance and pure protection, up 8.6% on the previous half year. Motor 237,421, property 85,527. Warranty complaints up 26.9%, travel up 26.4%. The FCA's review of home and travel claims found that only 32% of storm damage claims in its sample resulted in a payment

Sources: Ombudsman van de Verzekeringen, annual report 2025 and report page; AFM klachtenuitvraag verzekeraars 2025; Médiation de l'Assurance, rapport annuel 2025; FCA insurance complaints 2026 H1 and FCA home and travel claims review.

Two details matter for a CX lead. First, the refusal is rarely the whole complaint. In France, complaint handling and contract management were close to 40% of admissible referrals in 2020 and are 7% now, while refusals rose to 55%. Insurers fixed the complaint desk and left the decision unexplained. Second, the Belgian ombudsman's first recommendation for 2025 is about time, not cover: long settlement periods come largely from expert assessments, especially when each insurer appoints its own expert, although the technical findings are usually similar. One expert, agreed between insurers, would shorten the wait. The customer does not see the experts. The customer sees the months.

The five moments inside a claim, and what to measure at each

A claim is five touchpoints, and customers judge each one separately. Each deserves its own short transactional survey close to the event, with one score and one open question.

1. First notice

The report of the claim is the easiest moment to get right, and most insurers do. J.D. Power's property study finds 38% of claimants now report first notice of loss through a digital tool, 49% submit photos and 45% receive updates digitally, and satisfaction is higher for each group that does. Measure it anyway, because the first notice sets expectations for everything after. Ask one question: do you know what happens next and when? A customer who cannot answer will call.

2. The document request

Excessive or repeated documentation is on EIOPA's list of top five reasons for dissatisfaction, named by 19% of unhappy claimants. The damage is the second request for a document already sent, and the discovery that the channel was wrong all along. One public review of a Belgian insurer describes a seriously ill customer who submitted medical expenses through the app for months, then heard by chance on the phone that they should have gone by email. "I have already spoken to so many people and none have told me." Everyone in that chain had the information. Nobody owned the customer. Measure the document step with an effort score and read the comments for the words "again" and "already".

3. The silence

Between the documents and the decision there is a gap, and the gap is where chase calls are born. J.D. Power lists "frequent customer-initiated contacts" among the most common issues raised by the 34% of property claimants whose policy did not meet their expectations. In Belgium, the federal ombudsman network drew the same conclusion from more than 117,000 contacts in 2025. David Baele, who chairs it, says citizens and consumers want services that are reachable, understandable and human, and must know what the status of their file is and what the waiting times are. The fix is unglamorous: a status update the customer did not have to ask for, at fixed intervals, in plain language. Measure inbound contacts per open claim. It is the purest effort metric in the business.

4. The decision

The decision is the moment the policy becomes real. In France, refusals are 55% of admissible mediation files, and the mediator's annual report says the reasons for refusal are still very often not understood by the insured. In the UK, the FCA found home insurers failing to define what a storm is, which, combined with poor communication, led to high rejection rates and only 32% of storm claims paid. A refusal cannot always be avoided. An unexplained refusal can. Measure the decision with two questions: was the outcome explained in a way you understood, and did you have a chance to discuss it. The second is the gap J.D. Power names most often: lack of explanation, or of the opportunity to discuss the estimate or settlement.

5. The payout and after

Satisfaction often drops after the payout, not during reporting, and the drivers are the amount and the delay. A payout lower than expected is the first reason for dissatisfaction in the EU, at 23%. In the US property study, the final payment arrives on average 40.7 days after the claim, and the 19% of customers who faced a premium increase, out-of-pocket costs and a high deductible together scored 606, against 702 for the industry. Michel Stevens described the blind spot on our podcast: "We know how to process an insurance claim, for instance. But... we do not understand why we need to be swift with our answers when the customer asks, 'When do we need to pay?' or 'When do we get our money?'" Measure twice: at payout, and at the next renewal, when the customer decides what the experience was worth.

Brokers stand between you and the customer

In Belgium, brokers collected 52.1% of all premium income in 2024 and 61.2% of non-life premiums, and the direct channel held 19.3%. For most customers the broker is the insurer's face, at the sale and at the claim. The positive review in the same set as the medical expenses story praises clear communication by phone and email and a broker who was "present at the appointments" about water damage. That is the broker at their best, and the insurer gets the credit. At their worst, the broker absorbs the complaint, and the file at the ombudsman is the first the insurer hears of it.

The Belgian ombudsman adds a newer channel to watch: comparison sites that steer customers to online subscription, usually without any physical intermediary. Feedback through intermediaries needs its own approach. Survey the broker's customers after a claim with the insurer's name on the survey, so the answers reach the insurer. Survey the brokers themselves on the same five moments; they see the silence before the customer calls. The broker who writes "my clients keep asking me where the file is" is describing moment three.

Why the chatbot is not the relationship

The Belgian ombudsman made digital communication the first of five themes in its 2025 report. Chatbots and automated platforms, it writes, sometimes give standardised answers that are insufficiently adapted to individual situations, and the absence of a human contact and poor phone reachability hinder the resolution of more complex files. The bot is fine for a policy number. It fails at the moment that matters, which is always the complex one.

J.D. Power measures the cost of that failure. Auto claimants who completely agreed that their insurer gave them one consistent experience across channels scored 804. Those who disagreed scored 390, usually because they did not understand the explanations, had to ask in several channels, or found the digital tools not working. Insurers delivered that consistency 54% of the time, one of the lowest-performing indicators in the study. Mark Garrett, J.D. Power's director of global insurance intelligence, describes a market where repairs are faster and rates are falling, yet total losses still "can make for a poor customer experience". Trust and fairness of settlement rank first and second among the eight dimensions of claims satisfaction. Digital channels rank last.

How to measure insurance CX so it changes something

Insurance CX measurement works in three layers, and the layer insurers skip is the middle one. The relationship score at brand level, once or twice a year, is the number the annual report quotes. It barely moves, because most respondents have never claimed. Underneath it sits the transactional layer: a short survey after each of the five moments above, sent to claimants and, through the broker, to the broker's clients. Below both sits the open text at volume: survey comments, calls, emails to the claims desk and the reviews the ombudsman reads before you do. That text is where "they asked for the same document twice" lives. Our guide to customer feedback analysis covers how to read it at scale.

Two capabilities carry most of the weight. Key driver analysis ranks which topics move renewal, so the document loop or the settlement delay shows up as a driver with a weight rather than an anecdote in a claims committee. Forward-looking alerts catch a sentiment shift on one claim line, a storm week or a new document rule, before it becomes a category at the ombudsman. Customer interactions bring the unsolicited feedback from calls and emails into the same view as the surveys. That is how Hello Customer is set up for insurers whose claims desk and CX team need to read the same thing. The scoreboard matters because 48% of companies never calculate the financial impact of CX, as our 2026 study found. In insurance the calculation is short: claimants who renew against claimants who leave, by moment.

If you are choosing software, our comparisons of feedback software for insurance and feedback software for financial services set out the criteria. Banks face a close cousin of this problem in the fraud alert; our guide to customer experience in banking applies the same method there, as the telecom guide does for outages and bills. The series also covers customer experience in ecommerce and customer experience in utilities.

A 90-day start for an insurance CX lead

Start with one claim line, the one with the most volume or the most complaints, and run it for a quarter.

  1. Map the claim in the customer's words: "I don't know what happens next", "I sent that already", "nobody has called", "I don't understand why", "it took six weeks and it was less than I expected".
  2. Send one question after each moment, with an open field. Effort after the document request and the decision, satisfaction after the payout. Keep it under a minute.
  3. Count inbound contacts per open claim for four weeks. That is the baseline for the silence.
  4. Read every open answer, including the broker's. Tag the words that recur: "again", "already", "nobody", "when".
  5. Rank the drivers and fix the top one. In most lines it is a status update at fixed intervals, clearer document guidance up front or a named handler for the complex files.
  6. Call back every detractor within 48 hours and tell them what you changed. Then tell the brokers, who will repeat it to the next claimant. Our guide to closing feedback loops covers the mechanics.
  7. Report two numbers at day 90: effort per moment, and the renewal rate of surveyed claimants against the rest of the book.

Then add the next claim line, and the broker channel as a line of its own.

Frequently asked questions

What is customer experience in insurance?

Customer experience in insurance is the overall impression a customer forms of an insurer across every contact: the quote, the policy documents, the renewal and, above all, the claim. Because contacts are rare, the claim carries most of the weight. Regulators in Belgium, the Netherlands, France and the UK all report refused, delayed or unexplained claims as the main reason customers escalate.

Why does satisfaction drop after an insurance payout?

Because the payout is where the promise is tested. EIOPA finds that a payout lower than expected is the first reason for dissatisfaction among EU claimants, at 23%, ahead of the length of the process at 22%. J.D. Power's 2026 US auto claims study shows satisfaction rising for repairable claims and falling for total losses, down 46 points since 2023, with a score of 490 when the payout did not cover the car loan.

How do insurers measure customer experience?

In three layers. A relationship score at brand level once or twice a year; a transactional survey after each of the five moments of a claim (first notice, document request, the waiting period, the decision, the payout) with an effort or satisfaction question and one open field; and analysis of the open text from surveys, calls, emails and broker feedback. Key driver analysis then ranks which moments move renewal.

How should insurers collect feedback through brokers?

Brokers hold 61% of non-life premiums in Belgium, so many customers never contact the insurer directly. Survey the broker's clients after a claim with the insurer's name on the survey, survey the brokers themselves on the same five moments, and read the open text from both. A broker who reports that clients keep asking where their file is has named the moment to fix first.

Final thoughts

Insurers lose customers at a document asked for twice, a silence nobody broke, a refusal nobody explained and a payout that arrived late and short. The policy did what it said. The complaint maps from Brussels, Amsterdam, Paris and London say the same thing: the claim is where the relationship is decided, and the handling is what customers remember at renewal. Measure the five moments on their own, listen through the broker as well as around them, and act in the open. Peace of mind is the product. The claim is where you deliver it.

To see how an insurer reads feedback from claimants, brokers and the claims desk in one view, book a demo and we will walk through it with your own claim lines.

Curious what your own feedback would say?

Surveys, reviews, support tickets and calls in one place, with the open text classified and ranked by impact.

Request demo